Sunday, November 22, 2026

How to Live: Or A Life of Montaigne in One Question and Twenty Attempts at an Answer II

Since my last post, I've read the following chapters:
Use little tricks.
Question everything.
Keep a private room behind the shop.
Be convivial: live with others.
Wake from the sleep of habit.
Live temperately.

Generally, it is hard to disagree with Montaigne's recommendations, though I think it is necessary to make adjustments for social changes that have occurred since he was alive. His attitude in many situations was skepticism, but not in the modern scientific sense that requires a more rigorous procedure for determining the merits of an idea. Though I don't know his exact religious ideas, he appears to have been a practicing Catholic, which meant that he never had to face the persecution that many of his intellectual successors faced up until the French Revolution in 1789.  

Montaigne was unusually frank about sex, even by modern standards. He recognized that women often find sex unsatisfactory but cover it up or fantasize about someone else while engaging in it. He even admitted that he had a small penis! He also mentioned his decrease in libido as he aged. In other respects, he had a conventional, arranged marriage when he was thirty-two. It sounds as if he had nothing in common with his wife, Françoise, who was twenty on their wedding day. She could be opinionated, loud and aggressive, but was probably better than Montaigne in practical matters related to the management of their properties. They had several children, but only one, a girl, survived to adulthood. She outlived both the child and Montaigne. One of the most interesting facts in the book, I think, is that, even though they lived in a major wine district, and most of their income came from wine, Montaigne admitted late in life that he did not know what "fermenting wine" meant. I think that this could have been the basis for Silvio in El Rosedal, by Julio Ramón Ribeyro, though that context is quite different. Needless to say, Montaigne and Françoise were not close, but they did not violate the social norms of the time. Because they were wealthy, this was a situation that they could deal with easily. Montaigne lived in a separate tower on the property, where his library was located, and they did not spend much time together. Sex was purely for procreation. In many respects, this traditional form of marital relationships, which survives up to the present, is more realistic that what we have now in "liberated" marriages, in which men pretend to enjoy childrearing and women pretend to enjoy their boring careers. My Armenian grandparents also had an arranged marriage and lived in much the same manner as Montaigne and his wife. If you had asked them whether they had enjoyed sharing their lives together, they probably wouldn't have known what you were talking about. My grandfather spent his later years living in a separate section of the house. In recent years, there has been a tendency to dismiss Montaigne as a sexist, but I don't think that is a fair criticism when you consider that none of the women he knew were educated, and that what he liked the most was intelligent discussion. He probably would have liked George Eliot and Harriet Martineau, though he may have been intellectually intimidated by them.

One of Montaigne's lasting ideas may have been a precursor to the concept of the noble savage, later popularized by Rousseau. While he was alive, there was an active interest in France in Native Americans, and the French seem to have been more successful than the English or the Spanish at developing export markets and military support with help from Native Americans. I think that the noble savage concept remained popular in the U.S. at least up until Thoreau and Emerson, whereas it vacillated and eventually died in France when the French colonization of North America ended at about the time of the Louisiana Purchase. Another durable idea from Montaigne is probably the importance of male friendships. This was similarly picked up by Thoreau and Emerson, also Walt Whitman (who was gay) and, in France, by George Sand (who was bisexual). Montaigne seems to have been heterosexual and had an active sex life prior to his marriage. Our current concepts of sexuality would be quite foreign to him, and he probably thought that women were too different from men to identify closely with them. This makes sense biologically, but biology is far more complex than anyone realized during Montaigne's time.

I have about a third of the book left to finish.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated in order to remove spam.